Economic Scenario Generators
A deterministic projection is one weather forecast. An ESG writes many. One hundred annual Euler paths of Vasicek, CIR, or Hull–White discount the same classroom annuity. A correlated equity sleeve rides beside the short rate. This is not a calibrated vendor ESG and not a prescribed C3 scenario set.
01
Deterministic versus stochastic
A single discount rate answers “what if this path.” Monte Carlo answers “what is the distribution.” Cheap-rate paths make the annuity expensive; dear-rate paths make it cheap. High present value is the writer's loss, so the 95th percentile of liability PV is the expensive tail.
Analogy: one rainfall forecast versus a hundred. The mean tells you how much grain to plant. The expensive (high-PV) tail tells you whether the writer can fund the guarantee when rates stay cheap.
Vasicek and Hull–White let the short rate wander and pull it back toward a mean. CIR does the same but will not go below zero. Equity is a separate sleeve that can fall when rates rise if you set a negative correlation.
02
One hundred short-rate paths
Teaching lab
One hundred short-rate paths
Annual Euler steps for 20 years. Each path discounts the same $8 million classroom annuity. The seed is fixed, so a refresh does not invent a new fan. Not a calibrated ESG.
- Mean liability PV
- $110,107,225
- 5th percentile (cheap tail)
- $97,181,161
- 95th percentile (expensive tail)
- $124,990,722
- Mean equity sleeve
- $61,696,581
- Equity 5th / 95th
- $10,123,497 / $167,907,797
A deterministic projection is one weather forecast. An ESG writes many. Cheap-rate paths make the annuity expensive; dear-rate paths make it cheap. High present value is the writer's loss, so the 95th percentile of liability PV is the expensive tail.
03
Behind the scenes
- Draw a unit normal with a fixed seed so a refresh does not invent a new fan.
- Step the short rate once a year for 20 years under the chosen model.
- Pair an equity shock at correlation ρ and grow a $20 million sleeve as geometric Brownian motion.
- Discount the $8 million classroom annuity on each rate path.
- Rank the present values. Report mean, 5th, and 95th percentiles, and the equity fan.
04
Curves, calibration, and real-world versus risk-neutral
A production ESG starts from a yield curve: spot rates, forwards, and a discount curve. Calibration fits mean reversion and volatility so that the generator prices (or at least recovers) today’s curve and a volatility target. This lab skips that solve. Spot, forward, and discount construction stay on the yield curves lesson. Hull–White as a fitted short-rate model stays on Hull–White.
Economic / real-world scenarios are for planning, capital, and cash-flow testing: they can carry a risk premium. Risk-neutral scenarios are for pricing traded or embedded options: the drift is whatever keeps traded assets fair. Mixing the two is a common model-validation finding. Tail scenarios are the outer percentiles of the histogram. Adding paths is a crude variance reduction; a production shop would also use antithetics, control variates, or stratified sampling.
Scenario correlation here is one number ρ between the rate shock and the equity shock. A multi-factor ESG would add credit, inflation, and a full correlation matrix. Those factors are named, not simulated.
05
A real-world ALM use
A stochastic ALM run asks how wide the liability PV fan is at 100 versus 200 paths, and whether a higher rate volatility or a more negative equity correlation fattens the surplus tail. Raise σ, then raise path count, and watch the histogram and the standard teaching percentiles. Related typed-versus-drawn paths live on scenario generation.
06
Limitations
Annual Euler steps, one factor, a constant Hull–White θ, no credit, no inflation, no prescribed statutory scenario set, and no curve calibration. The equity sleeve is GBM with a constant ρ. Percentiles from 100 paths are noisy. Do not treat the fan as a C3 or ORSA result.
Related pages: Advanced ALM hub · Advanced quantitative finance · Sensitivity & stress testing.
