Learn / Learn by Doing · Lesson 9 of 10
Fund NAV estimation and proxy risk
Prerequisites: Understanding fund holdings and overlap · Reading market data correctly
01 · Overview & Worked Setup
Mutual-fund NAV is typically calculated after the U.S. cash close. ETF shares trade all day, so price can sit away from NAV. A proxy that multiplies yesterday’s weights by today’s stock prints inherits every stale name, every foreign session that has not opened, and every FX print you chose.
Tracking difference versus a benchmark is another gap: fees, sampling, and timing. None of those gaps is a 15:45 ET observation. Live fund cards stay on Research.
Teaching lab
NAV versus the traded price
Mutual-fund NAV is usually struck after the close. An ETF trades all day. A proxy that uses old holdings, foreign hours, or a benchmark map can miss both.
- NAV
- 100 $/share
- Market
- 100.4 $/share
- Gap
- $0.40
- Holdings vintage
- 30 days old
Market minus NAV. Premium or discount, not a forecast.
Stale weights increase proxy error. Missing names are not treated as cash.
What this scenario means
An index level is not a fund share. A teaching proxy is not a 15:45 ET observation. Live Research dashboards stay on Research.
Guided challenge
If holdings are 60 days old and the fund traded a name that no longer appears, is the proxy complete?
Educational simulation only. Hypothetical results are not forecasts or trade recommendations. Hypothetical classroom numbers. One standard contract is 100 shares unless labeled otherwise. Not a live quote, not a fill, and not a probability forecast.
02 · Worked example: $100 NAV, $100.40 traded
Gap = $0.40. That can be an ETF premium, a stale NAV, or a proxy using 30-day-old holdings. It is not automatically 'cheap' or 'rich'.
If 20% of the book is foreign and those markets are closed, a U.S.-hours proxy is a partial map. Missing weight is not treated as cash.
03 · Assumptions and limits
Single NAV versus single market print. No FX tape. No claim that delayed Yahoo equals official NAV. Educational only.
Checking for a quiz…
Teaching numbers only — not a live quote, not a fill, not financial advice. All lessons · Back to Practice · Replay · Journal.
