Learn / Understand the Trade · Lesson 6 of 8

Intermediate

Probability of profit versus expected value

Prerequisites: Position sizing and risk budgets · Choosing a strike price

01 · Overview & Worked Setup

Probability of profit asks how often a path finishes above break-even. Expected value asks what those paths average in dollars. A structure that wins 70% of the time at +$100 and loses 30% at −$400 has expected value −$50. The win rate is still 70%.

Model 'confidence' scores and delta-as-probability shortcuts are not this calculation. Here the probabilities are stated, they sum to one, and the dollars include the debit or credit you actually paid. Costs and tails go in the outcomes, not in a footnote.

Teaching lab

Frequent wins, negative expected value

Two exhaustive classroom outcomes. Probabilities must sum to 1. Expected value is the probability-weighted dollar result, not the win rate.

5% – 95%
20$ – 400$
-800$ – -20$
$Win $100Loss $-400EV $-50
Values in $; bars extend from zero. Negative values are losses when the measure is P/L.
Win $
100 $
Loss $
-400 $
EV $
-50 $
Loss probability
30%
Expected value
−$50.00

What this scenario means

A 70% win rate at +$100 against a 30% loss at −$400 has EV −$50. Probability of profit is not expected value. Tails matter.

Guided challenge

For the fixed example +$100 on a win and -$400 on a loss, what is EV at a 90% win rate?

Educational simulation only. Hypothetical results are not forecasts or trade recommendations. Hypothetical classroom numbers. One standard contract is 100 shares unless labeled otherwise. Not a live quote, not a fill, and not a probability forecast.

Stress dollars in What If →

02 · Worked example: 70% winners, negative EV

0.70 × $100 + 0.30 × (−$400) = $70 − $120 = −$50. Adding $2 of spread cost on every trial makes EV worse, not better.

A credit spread can show a high probability of keeping the credit and still have poor EV if the max-loss wing is large. Size from the loss budget lesson before you celebrate the win rate.

03 · Assumptions and limits

Two exhaustive states. Real markets have many paths. This is not implied probability from a chain and not a Monte Carlo. Monte Carlo on this site draws paths; it does not certify EV.

Checking for a quiz…

Teaching numbers only — not a live quote, not a fill, not financial advice. All lessons · Back to Practice · Replay · Journal.

Trades | Learn. Practice. Analyze. Improve.