Tools

All calculators

Roth vs Traditional

Answers: under one named comparison basis, what are after-tax modeled balances? It does not decide deductibility, conversion, RMDs, or a general winner.

Example math. Caps and tax rates are labeled inputs, not live IRS tables. Not financial advice.

Beginning-of-year annual additions, then one full-year return, identical for both accounts. Tax saved now is an undiscounted sum over modeled years, not a present value and not invested.

Tax year 2026 labeled defaults, verified 2026-11-04 from IRS IR-2025-111. The typed cap is an assumption, not an eligibility determination. Catch-up and income limits are not applied. IRS Roth IRA rules.

The typed amount is pre-tax pay available to save. Traditional deposits that full amount. Roth deposits the after-tax remainder at the current marginal rate.

$ per year

Pre-tax pay available to save. Traditional deposits this amount; Roth deposits the after-tax remainder at the current marginal rate.

Example: $7,000 Valid range 0 to 1000000.

whole years

Number of annual additions and growth steps.

Example: 20 Valid range 0 to 80, whole numbers.

% per year

Same assumed return and same beginning-of-year deposit timing for both accounts.

Example: 7 Valid range -99.99 to 1000.

%

Assumed marginal rate on a deductible contribution, not an average tax rate. Deductibility is an assumption.

Example: 22 Valid range 0 to 100.

%

Assumed rate applied once to modeled Traditional withdrawals. Not a forecast of future law.

Example: 22 Valid range 0 to 100.

Roth yearly contribution

$5,460.00

Traditional yearly contribution

$7,000.00

Roth current cash cost (all years)

$109,200.00

Traditional current cash cost (all years)

$109,200.00

Assumes a full current deduction.

Roth after tax (qualified assumption)

$239,503.87

Traditional after withdrawal tax

$239,503.87

Traditional tax saved now (undiscounted sum)

$30,800.00

Not invested in this model.

Equal pre-tax budget: current cash costs match under a full deduction. Any remaining gap is from different retirement tax, not from unequal contributions.

Show numerical table
Roth versus Traditional cash cost and after-tax value
MeasureRothTraditional
Yearly contribution$5,460.00$7,000.00
Current cash cost, all years$109,200.00$109,200.00
After-tax modeled value$239,503.87$239,503.87
After-tax modeled value
After-tax modeled valueRoth after-tax value versus Traditional after withdrawal tax under the selected comparison basis. Vertical axis: After-tax dollars. Horizontal axis: Account. Traditional: After-tax value $239,503.87.After-tax dollars$0$100k$200k$300kRothTraditionalAccount

Traditional: After-tax value $239,503.87

  • After-tax value (bars)
Theory and worked example

Equal 22% taxes, $7,000 pre-tax, one year, 0% return: Roth contributes $5,460 and Traditional $7,000; both end at $5,460 after tax.

Trades | Learn. Practice. Analyze. Improve.