Tools & calculators 路 Beginner 路 4 min
Use the Roth vs Traditional calculator
Equal pre-tax budget or equal account deposits, with tax assumptions labeled.
Last source-verified . Runtime data and availability may vary.
Open this featureLearn
What this lesson is for
Equal pre-tax budget or equal account deposits, with tax assumptions labeled.
Access: Public; no account is needed for the calculator.
Before you open it
- A modern browser with JavaScript enabled for interactive controls.
You will be able to
- Equal pre-tax budget or equal account deposits, with tax assumptions labeled.
See
Walk through the screen
Open Tools and choose Roth vs Traditional. Read the assumption and disclaimer above the form.
Check the units for Years, Annual return, Current marginal tax rate, Retirement tax rate. The field reference below explains the displayed controls.
Enter illustrative inputs within the displayed bounds. Change one assumption at a time and resolve any field errors before reading results.
Choose Equal pre-tax budget or Equal account deposits before entering the budget. These comparison bases use different current cash costs.
Inspect Roth yearly contribution, Traditional yearly contribution, Roth current cash cost (all years), Traditional current cash cost (all years), Roth after tax (qualified assumption), Traditional after withdrawal tax, Traditional tax saved now (undiscounted sum). Read supporting help and any available numerical table before comparing scenarios.
Use Reset this calculator to return to its configured example inputs if you want to start again. Resetting a calculator does not edit Journal records.
Field reference
- Years (whole years)
- Number of annual additions and growth steps.
Illustrative example: 20
- Annual return (% per year)
- Same assumed return and same beginning-of-year deposit timing for both accounts.
Illustrative example: 7
- Current marginal tax rate (%)
- Assumed marginal rate on a deductible contribution, not an average tax rate. Deductibility is an assumption.
Illustrative example: 22
- Retirement tax rate (%)
- Assumed rate applied once to modeled Traditional withdrawals. Not a forecast of future law.
Illustrative example: 22
Try
Worked example
Illustrative field examples: Years: 20; Annual return: 7; Current marginal tax rate: 22; Retirement tax rate: 22. These are teaching values, not recommended settings or forecasts.
Your task
Change one input in Roth vs Traditional, describe which result changes, then reset the calculator and explain its stated assumptions.
Verify
Expected result
Equal pre-tax budget or equal account deposits, with tax assumptions labeled. Result cards include Roth yearly contribution, Traditional yearly contribution, Roth current cash cost (all years), Traditional current cash cost (all years), Roth after tax (qualified assumption), Traditional after withdrawal tax, Traditional tax saved now (undiscounted sum).
Common mistakes
- Read the field-level unit and validation message. Percent inputs, whole-year bounds, zero cases, and deposit timing can differ between calculators.
- If no result appears, correct invalid or blank inputs; do not interpret a missing result as zero.
Progress is anonymous and local to this browser. It does not sync with your account.
